Nancy and Sluggo
Sluggo meets a new friend Irma at Nancy's party, where all were, either Truth Tellers or Liars. Irma tells Sluggo that she has overheard a conversation in which a girl revealed her identity, saying she is a liar. Now sluggo is thinking, Is Irma a Liar or a Truth teller ?
What will you tell, if Sluggo ask you ?
What will you tell, if Sluggo ask you ?
Labels: logic, trickofmind
posted by Rajesh Lal at
8:00 PM
13 Comments:
Irma is a Liar.
wouldn't she lie and say she was a truth teller if she was a liar? no matter what she said to revealed her identity she would have said she was a truth teller. thats why I would say Irma is a liar...
Sluggo has no way of knowing if Irma is a Liar or a Truth teller because she just said she overheard a conversation, which has nothing to do with what the conversation is about.
Irma is a liar...
She couldn't have overheard a girl reveal her identity as a liar. If that girl really was a liar she would reveal herself as a truth teller, which would be a lie. If she was a truth teller she would tell the truth and say she was a truth teller. Either way Irma couldn't have overheard someone reveal themself as a liar. Therefore Irma is lying and is a LIAR!
BUSTED!!!
You say Irma is a liar...if you're a truth teller. What if you're a liar?
I think same as meg. In addition Truth tellers can not say they are liers.
RD
i would say irma is a truth teller because i'm is a liar =]
sorry. i meant to say i'm a liar. not i'm is a liar
irma is truth teller coz she just said what she overheard, weather the overheard conversation was true or lie it doesnt matter.
since I´m a liar, I´d say that Irma is a truth teller
Lets all agree, the cake is a lie.
what if sluggo lied to you about what she had told him, if you dont know who is a liar and who is a truth teller then theres no real way to tell, spartan_727
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home